Over 230 years ago, James Madison wrote the Second Amendment to protect the right of people to use hard-to-fire muskets in well-regulated militia in defense of the State. On December 2, the Supreme Court will decide whether virtually any adult has a right to AR-15s and AK-47s––the weapons of choice for mass shooters in the U.S. and cartels in Mexico––to use as they choose. And the Court’s conservative super-majority asserts that faithfulness to history guides them in gun cases.
Global Action on Gun Violence’s amicus brief explains how the Supreme Court’s Second Amendment jurisprudence has gone off the rails, while urging the Court to uphold state and local assault-weapons restrictions challenged in Viramontes v. Cook County. Among other points raised, GAGV explains that proponents of striking down assault weapons bans rely in part on assault weapons’ popularity with foreign criminal organizations to support their arguments. That should not be accepted – and it highlights much of what is wrong about the Court’s test.
Mexican Crime Guns Shouldn’t Create a Constitutional Right
GAGV’s brief highlights a largely overlooked issue relevant to the case: a significant portion of the demand for U.S.-sold assault weapons comes from Mexican drug cartels and other foreign criminal organizations.
That matters because Petitioners’ constitutional argument rests heavily on production and sales figures. They contend that weapons “in common use” are protected by the Second Amendment, that millions of assault weapons have been sold in the United States, and therefore there is a Constitutional right to AR-15s.
There’s a few problems with this argument, as GAGV’s brief points out. First, sales are not the same as possession by law-abiding Americans for lawful purposes. Hundreds of thousands of assault rifles are purchased in the United States by straw purchasers for foreign criminal organizations, including Mexican cartels. A rifle bought in Texas or Arizona and trafficked to Mexico or elsewhere (or interdicted by law enforcement before making it across the border) remains part of the U.S. manufacturing and sales total cited by Petitioners to argue that assault weapons are in “common use.” Yet that rifle may be used in Mexico to protect a drug shipment, enforce cartel control, commit a kidnapping, attack a rival organization, or confront police or military forces. These weapons are highly prized by cartels, often selling “for double the purchase price or more in Mexico.” Estimates suggest that “between 250,000 to 1 million firearms [are] trafficked from the U.S. to Mexico each year.”
The problem is not limited to Mexico. U.S.-sourced firearms are trafficked to criminal organizations and armed groups in Haiti, Central America, the Caribbean, and elsewhere. These groups seek assault weapons for the same reason legislatures seek to restrict them: the weapons enable the fast and effective exercise of extraordinary destructive force. Yet Petitioners count those transactions as evidence of constitutionally protected American ownership without addressing the substantial foreign criminal demand that helped produce them.
Popularity Should Not Create a Constitutional Right
GAGV also exposes a more fundamental defect in the Supreme Court’s current Second Amendment doctrine. Even if assault weapons were “in common use,” commercial popularity should not create a constitutional right. If it did, manufacturers could flood the market for exceptionally dangerous weapons – like .50 caliber sniper rifles, that have a mile range and can shoot down helicopters – and if they sold enough of them before they were banned, those guns would be constitutionally protected and could not be regulated.
And the gun lobby should be careful what it wishes for, because if popularity can create a constitutional right, declining popularity can extinguish it. A firearm protected today could lose that protection if consumer tastes change and ownership wanes. But that’s absurd: Constitutional rights should not ebb and flow with shifts in consumer taste or market share.
Constitutionality Should Consider Public Safety and the Right to Live
GAGV also argues that the Court should get rid of the historical test adopted in New York State Rifle & Pistol Ass’n v. Bruen and return to a means-end analysis that considers the burden a law imposes on lawful self-defense alongside the government’s public safety reasons for regulating exceptionally lethal weapons. Even if the Second Amendment is read to protect some right to shoot guns, the Constitution must also protect a right to not be shot.
Before Bruen, courts generally evaluated firearm restrictions by considering both the burden on individual rights and the government’s reasons for adopting the law. That approach allowed courts to protect gun possession for lawful self-defense while accounting for the actual dangers posed by particular weapons.
GAGV’s brief explains that assault-weapons laws demonstrate why that framework is superior.
The burden imposed by assault weapons restrictions is limited. The laws do not prevent law-abiding people from defending themselves or their homes. Handguns—the firearms most commonly selected for personal protection—remain available for law-abiding people, as do many models of shotguns and rifles.
The governmental interests are exceptionally strong. Assault-weapons restrictions seek to reduce the lethality of mass shootings, protect police and first responders, disrupt international trafficking, and limit the firepower available to cartels and other armed groups.
Means-end scrutiny would permit courts to evaluate those interests directly. Judges could ask whether the law materially burdens lawful self-defense, whether the government has strong evidence of the harms it seeks to prevent, and whether the restriction is appropriately tailored while leaving adequate alternatives available.
Bruen instead directs courts toward historical analogies from eras that knew nothing of weapons comparable to modern assault rifles, or mass shootings, or international firearms-trafficking networks, or cartels equipped to confront national militaries. Eighteenth- or 19th century history cannot meaningfully answer every question created by 21st-century weapons and 21st-century criminal organizations.
GAGV’s brief argues that the Court can uphold these laws by recognizing that assault weapons are dangerous and that Petitioners’ raw sales statistics do not prove common lawful use. But the brief further asserts that the Court should also confront the larger problem revealed by the case and revisit its disastrous Bruen decision. A constitutional test should not allow commercial popularity—including popularity fueled by foreign criminal demand—to determine the scope of a right. Nor should legislatures trying to counter crime, mass shootings, and firearm trafficking be required to justify modern regulations by identifying historical analogues in a society to which regulating assault weapons would have been as foreign as regulating Instagram.
The Court should take this opportunity to revisit Bruen and restore means-end scrutiny, allowing courts to protect lawful self-defense while considering the real-world dangers assault weapons pose at home and abroad.
GAGV is registered under the FARA as an agent for the Governments of Mexico and the Bahamas. Additional information is available at the U.S Department of Justice, Washington DC.




"To ban guns because the criminals use them is to tell the law abiding that their rights and liberties depend not on their own conduct, but on the conduct of the guilty and lawless." - Lysander Spooner